The Olympics vs. American Idol: Scoring versus Voting
Last night was an interesting evening for seeing two different methods of determining "winners" to a contest. I am comparing the results of the free skate program of the Vancouver Olympic women's figure skating competition to the "elimination round" of the American Idol competition. First in skating, there can be no dispute. Kim Yuna skated an extremely technical, difficult routine, but skated it nearly flawlessly and with grace. She was judged by the same set of expert judges who scored all the other skaters of the evening, and they each gave specific points to her for each element she performed and how well she performed them. Because they have very specific criteria on how to judge (number of revolutions, position of skates on the ice, wobbles, precision of skate circles, etc) it is difficult to dispute the scores she received. In reality I think the judges may have scored all the skaters high, but frankly that is perfectly fair since they were all the same