Wash U Economist attacks Northside plan numbers
One of the more interesting news articles yesterday was that the chair of our Economics department here was being called upon for a court case against Paul McKee's redevelopment efforts on the northside of the city. The faculty member, Michele Boldrin, kept calling it "pie in the sky" with his best argument being about the 6,000 single family homes with an average price of about $450,000. He asks "Where are these 6,000 homeowners who can afford $450,000 homes going to come from?" That is a very good question! Personally I believe redevelopment on the northside of the city would be fantastic, but only if it is done realistically. That is a lot of fairly high priced homes to be for sale in the city. If there were 6,000 of those homes out in the county it would still be hard to sell so many of them, but in the city it would be next to impossible. In fact I checked one of my favorite local housing websites, stlouis.blockshopper.com. If you look at the sales statistics there and look at the year 2009, a total of 6,000 homes would cover all the homes sales in Florissant (incorporated and unincorporated), O'Fallon, St Peters, St. Charles, University City and Ferguson combined in 2009. That's a lot of homes! If you look at sales by region in West County, for example, the total in 2009 for all of West County was 2500 houses sold. So McKee wants to build more than twice as many homes as were sold in all of West County in the past year.
Comments